Community Viewpoint: Closing an Estate Tax Loophole?

One of the bills our legislature sent up to Gov. Ige to be signed, which is almost certain to become law because the Department of Taxation sponsored it, is one to close an estate tax “loophole.”  The issue isn’t as simple as it might seem, however.

First, some background.  An estate tax is imposed when a person dies.  The Federal Government imposes it when a decedent owned more than $5.45 million at death.  The federal tax rate brackets start from 18% and go to 40%.  Only fifteen U.S. states have an estate tax, and Hawaii is one of them.  Our law generally conforms to federal law, but our tax rates go from 10% to 15.7%.  (Six states impose an inheritance tax, which is similar except that the tax falls upon the heirs; of these, two states also have an estate tax.)

For a person’s estate to have an estate tax liability, the estate is usually substantial, and may include assets in more than one place.  For a person who doesn’t reside here, we tax assets that are located, or “sitused,” in Hawaii.  For a person who does reside here, we tax all property in the federal taxable estate, but give credit for estate or inheritance taxes paid to other states.

What happens if there is an entity, like a corporation or a LLC, that owns property?  Because an entity doesn’t die, the estate tax isn’t imposed on the entity.  But entities have owners.  Corporations have stockholders, for example.  So, the estate tax reaches the value of those ownership interests, such as corporate stock.  So far, so good; an individual can’t beat the estate tax by throwing property into an entity.  But an individual can use an entity to “situs shift.”  Suppose the individual lives in Ohio and the entity owns valuable real property in Hawaii.  The entity is not subject to Hawaii estate tax, and neither is the individual, because the shares of stock are generally sitused to the individual’s place of residence.  Lo and behold, Ohio doesn’t have an estate tax, so this estate will not be taxed in any state!  This is the loophole the bill addresses.

The bill says that if the entity is a single member LLC that has not elected to be taxed as a corporation, then the estate owning the LLC will need to pay estate tax in Hawaii the same as if the decedent owned the Hawaii property directly.

But wait.  The bill doesn’t plug the loophole completely.  In the situation just described, Hawaii estate tax can be avoided regardless of the type of entity, while the fix only works if the entity owning the Hawaii assets is a single member LLC disregarded for income tax purposes.  Thus, if the entity is a partnership, a LLC with more than one owner, or a LLC that has opted to be taxed as a corporation (perhaps a S corporation), the fix doesn’t apply and the loophole remains.

Furthermore, how does the Department think it would be able to implement and enforce this law if it is enacted?  The Department might be able to find out about a nonresident decedent who owned Hawaii property if there is a Hawaii ancillary probate, which would be needed to distribute Hawaii realty and other Hawaii assets, but how would it even find out about an LLC that owns Hawaii property and has a recently deceased owner?  Even if the Department can keep an eye on all the Hawaii properties owned by LLCs, how could it watch their owners?  In theory, LLCs that do business in Hawaii, wherever organized, need to register with the Department of Commerce and Consumer Affairs, but the registration form does not require the LLC to state who the owners are, just that a list of the owners will be kept on file at the company’s principal office.

In all, this bill seems like a knee-jerk reaction to a perceived problem.  If this situs-shifting anomaly is a loophole that needs closing, it’s very doubtful whether this bill will accomplish it.  Well, we can see what happens.

The MAUIWatch Community Network invites readers to express their views in the Community Viewpoint. Community Viewpoint columns should be on or around 800 words. Community Viewpoint submissions are subject to editing. We do not print letters announcing events to come, extensive quotations from other material, open letters or form letters. Send to contact (at) mauiwatch (dot) com



About Tom Yamachika

Tom Yamachika
Tom Yamachika is the President of the Tax Foundation of Hawaii, a private, nonprofit educational organization dedicated to informing the taxpaying public about the finances of our state and local governments in Hawaii. Tom is also a tax attorney in solo practice and has been since early 2013. Prior to 2013, he was with the accounting firm Accuity LLP, which was formed in 2006 from the Honolulu office of Coopers & Lybrand (which later became PricewaterhouseCoopers). Before that, he served as an Administrative Rules Specialist in the State of Hawaii Department of Taxation from 1994 to 1996, where he drafted rules, interpretive releases, and legislation on several different state taxes. Prior to that, he practiced litigation and tax law with Cades Schutte Fleming & Wright in Honolulu.

Check Also

TAXWatch: Loophole? On the Way to the Top

O n Wednesday, August 14, the Senate Committee on Hawaiian Affairs held an “informational briefing” …